Hi Magnar
There's no historical choice to exclude comments at all. Rating, on the other hand, is ..err .. banned. To close this rating topic, before continuing with the comments, here's what can be said. AMP aims to be a repository. Rating is subject to taste, and, taste is based on scale that varies. We want facts, nothing else. I was admin at Nectarine and I know for a fact that it's not good to allow votes
Now, about comments. Well, I can split my reply into several parts :
- No comment for now, as there is no user management. So, nothing is open. Plain and simple. And this very point closes the topic I guess

- There has been some discussion about adding _author_ comments (so, not listeners). But we don't really know how to display those. A new page ? A popup ? etc.
- we already have some info about music files (displaying samples and all), and some party ranks (all in the DB right now). But again, no time spent to think about a way to display those.
All in all, I guess that comments are welcome as long as they come from either the author or someone very close to the author (same group, same dev team, etc.).
I would push it to add those "modinfo" data, as well as party info, when available.
In fact, I'm planing to add a new button in the module list, like "info". But then, once clicked, then what ?

Why not discuss it here ? Monty ? Crown ? Curt Cool ? Anybody ?
Cheers
Sylvain